Recessed walnut entry door beside pale split-face stone, with wide stone steps and an oak tree at left.

Portola Valley’s Historic Roadhouse Seeks Approval for a Kitchen Expansion

October 1, 2026

In August 1976, a pair of scientists from SRI International walked out to the picnic tables behind a beer garden at the corner of Alpine and Arastradero roads and sent what's credited as the first internet transmission. They picked the spot because it was close to Stanford and open late. Fifty years later, the same picnic tables sit behind a building that still serves burgers on the same footprint, and the Town of Portola Valley is now reviewing a planning application to expand its kitchen space.

That building is Rossotti's Alpine Inn, known locally as Zott's. The application, filed by Portola Valley residents Deke and Lori Hunter, is currently in the town's public meeting process, with review by the Architectural and Site Control Commission still ahead. If it goes through, it will be the most significant physical change to the property since the Hunters and their partners rescued it from near-collapse in 2019.

What the 2026 Filing Actually Proposes

The plan is narrow and specific. It calls for tearing out a 450-square-foot lean-to and a 153-square-foot outdoor bar on the garden side of the building and replacing both with roughly 1,158 square feet of new kitchen space. The project is designed to stay within the restaurant's existing Conditional Use Permit, meaning it's a renovation of capacity and code compliance, not a request to change what the property is allowed to be. Anyone who wants to weigh in can email the assigned project planner, Jake Garcia, at the town's planning department, with "Alpine Inn" in the subject line, according to the town's own project page.

That page doesn't include a construction start date. Given how the last major rebuild went, that absence is worth noting rather than filling in with a guess.

The Kitchen Plan St. Claire Discussed in 2019

The idea of a professional kitchen at Zott's predates the current filing. When the Hunters and their partners reopened the tavern in August 2019 after a six-month closure, operating partner Greg St. Claire was already describing what came next. He told reporters at the time that he was thinking about "Phase II" and a plan to build out a genuine professional kitchen, according to The Almanac's coverage of the reopening. Seven years passed between that comment and an actual filing at Town Hall.

In the meantime, the ownership group made smaller additions instead. In June 2025, they installed a 1972 Argosy trailer behind the building, rebranded as the Wunder Bar, serving oysters, ceviche and strawberry frosé on weekends. It expanded what the property could offer without touching the main kitchen.

The 2026 filing is what happens when a seven-year-old plan finally becomes a document with square footage attached to it.

A Building With More Names Than Owners

Part of what makes this property different from a typical restaurant renovation is that it isn't really one restaurant's history. It's several, stacked on top of each other since Felix Buelna built the original structure in 1852, according to a history compiled by Palo Alto Online. A separate account, tied to a bronze plaque on the property, dates continuous roadhouse operation to 1868. Both dates are printed somewhere on the building. Nobody has reconciled them, and the discrepancy has outlasted several ownership groups.

The building has operated under at least five different names before its current one:

  • Casa de Tableta, the original gambling retreat Buelna built for Mexican-Californios and Gold Rush-era settlers
  • Black Chapete's, under early owner William Stanton
  • The Wunder, under Charles Schenkel in the early 1900s
  • E. Rossotti Beer Garden, after Enrico Rossotti took over the lease when Prohibition ended in 1933, the source of the "Zott's" nickname that stuck
  • Alpine Inn Beer Garden, starting in 1956 under Don Horther and John and Molly Alexander
  • Alpine Inn, its current name under the Hunter ownership group

Portola Valley historian Nancy Lund has described the property's founding as starting with either a gift or a wager. Buelna's own grandson believes his grandfather lost the land in a rigged poker game at the old Searsville Saloon. Nobody has ever confirmed it either way. The town's old nickname, "Roadhouse Valley," comes directly from buildings like this one.

The Scale Behind the Kitchen Filing

An SFGate feature published in August 2025 put a number on what Zott's actually does in a year: roughly $12 million in sales, with owners taking none of it as profit. The same reporting put daily volume at around 1,000 tickets a day, with regulars packing a couple hundred people into the tavern and creekside beer garden at peak times. One regular reportedly arrives on horseback to skip the parking line.

Those figures set the scale for the kitchen filing, since one kitchen serves all of those tickets. Lori Hunter, who led the 2019 restoration, said at the time, according to The Almanac, that the partners wanted the place to "live on for another 167 years." The seven years between the first mention of a professional kitchen and the planning file line up with the long horizon the partners described.

Two Gathering Points, Two Different Clocks

Portola Valley's Town Center at 765 Portola Road is where the town's actual civic life happens on a schedule. A certified farmers market runs there every Thursday from 2 to 6 p.m., followed most weeks by a free evening concert, a tradition the Cultural Arts Committee started in 2010 and that has hosted more than 40 bands since. In August, the Town Center also hosts PV Palooza, an all-day music festival that ran its fifth annual edition on August 29, 2026, from 10:30 a.m. to 8:30 p.m., funded by local business sponsors rather than town revenue.

Zott's runs on a different clock entirely. It doesn't close for winter, doesn't need a festival committee, and has been drawing crowds to the same corner of Alpine Road since before the Town Center existed in any form. One is scheduled and funded a season at a time. The other has been standing since a wager or a gift in 1852, has changed hands and names more than half a dozen times, and is now going through a public permitting process most residents will never sit in on unless they read the town's project page.

What This Means If You're Already Here

The filing is still early. There's no construction start date published, and the town's process still includes ASCC review before anything moves toward permits. Based on how the 2019 rebuild went, a project of this scope likely means a closure at some point, probably measured in months rather than weeks. Nothing on the town's page suggests that's imminent, and the ownership group's pattern so far, adding the Wunder Bar incrementally rather than shutting down for a single big push, suggests they may try to keep some version of the place open through the work.

Portola Valley has no traffic lights and no streetlights, and residents at the hardware store and grocery can still run a tab, the kind of detail that shows up in feature writing about the town precisely because it's still true. The town's only real commercial cluster is a couple of businesses near Alpine and Arastradero roads. A kitchen expansion at a landmark this well used is a change residents may want to follow, and the public comment process is open to anyone who emails a planner named Jake Garcia.

If you've been meaning to weigh in before the ASCC review moves forward, that email address is sitting on the town's own project page right now.

Portola Valley doesn't hand you many chances to watch its own history get written in real time. This is one of them, and it's happening at a building most residents have already eaten at a hundred times without knowing what's next for its kitchen. If you're thinking about what makes a town like this work, not just what a home here costs but what keeps people staying for generations, that's a conversation Matt Aragoni has with Portola Valley residents and buyers regularly. Reach out to talk about the town, not just the listings in it.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Matt

I am your San Mateo County Real Estate Expert, growing up San Mateo County has given me a highly specialized insight into the local markets here. I provide my clients/network with the most up-to-date market info, local expertise, and 5 Star Quality Client Service.